NO.

you're NOT in the right position to express "our feelings."
you're NOT in the right position to voice out "our thoughts"

you're hardly ever there.
you just catch us in a bad moment everytime.
and just because of that, it DOESN'T gives you any rights to evaluate and judge the whole situation.

YES.

you were being a good friend by telling her the truth.

BUT.

it's not ENTIRELY true.

as I said, you're hardly ever there to see what's really going on.
if you were, you would have just kept your big mouth shut about this whole situation.
YOU HAD NO PLACE AT ALL TO INTERFERE LIKE THAT.

you're just being selfish.
not to US, but to HER.
honestly, now that she has no friends, under the impression that you gave her, who is she going to hang round with when YOU'RE not there?
and frankly, you're NEVER there.
today was a rare moment and TADA, wreak the whole "moment" why don't you? BRAINIAC.

don't play good guy here and try to mop and feel bad bout making her cry based on the "truth"
IF you had use your brains and came up to each one of us and asked what we REALLY think and feel, then maybe, JUST MAYBE, oh I don't know, she wouldn't have cried?

and do you know why she cried?

thanks to your big mouth and that empty head of yours.
it wasn't even the TRUTH.

YOU made her cried based on your lies.
YOU made her cried just right after the birthday which was yesterday.

see, IF you were really thinking bout HER FEELINGS instead of YOUR FACE, then you would have not tell her today.

BECAUSE

it was HER BIRTHDAY yesterday.
and formal's in like 2 weeks time.

BUT NOOOOOO,

because you're not even a friend to her, you didn't know when her birthday was.
either that or you just really can't be stuffed of how she feels,
as long as you get your I'm-such-a-good-friend status.
well, GOOD JOB you idiot.
you got it.

and at what cost?
was it even worth it?

NO.
it was COMPLETELY unnecessery, uncompassionate, unfriend-like, stupid, arrogant, not worth it.

but again I say,
it's good that the cat is FINALLY out of the bag.
WE are to much of a chicken to tell it straight to her face, I'll hand that to you.
you did a good job of laying it out so "delicately".
BUT we're not ARROGANT, in the sense of the timing to tell her the "truth" like you did.
YOU might or might not know it was her birthday yesterday, either way, YOU HAVE A REALLY BAD TIMING to break news to "friends".
and this is because you just want your stupid arrogant face to be under a good impression from her point of view.

and YOU want to be annoyed and angry at us?
so be it then.
play the god in this whole scene that YOU have created..
because frankly, you're too stubborn to listen anyways.
so why bother?

I don't hate you.
I just can never look at you the same anymore.

but THANK YOU for telling her the truth.
NO THANK YOU for not getting the whole truth first before telling her the "truth" and making the whole thing worst.